AR-15 vs. By Tom McHale. Having a pistol caliber carbine or little AR pistol chambered in 9mm or 45 ACP isnt a bad option for inside the home. Therefore, I'm going to have to hold off on giving the AR-15 pistol a thumbs-up as a home defense option until I learn more. Twitter. Specifications Custom Pistol Lower Assembly (Home Build) The down side is the carbine is a bit awkward to use in confined spaces. Not optimal, but at least out of a carbine the 9mm has sufficient velocity to be effective. Both of these are pistol caliber carbines, that being a rifle sized weapon that shoots pistol bullets. 9mm Carbines are steadily gaining traction in the world of firearm sports and home defense so dont be a laggard, pick one up ASAP and enjoy sharing one type of ammo and perhaps even one type of magazine with your favorite hand cannons! There is also a .40 caliber version. The Sentry 12: A New Kind of Shotgun. Yes, shooting a pistol with one hand is usually less accurate than shooting a pistol with two hands, but shooting a long gun with one hand is much more difficult than shooting with two hands. Just because you put a pistol round into a rifle doesn't mean that it will perform like a rifle round. A carbines recoil is a small jolt, making the gun accurate when firing quickly. Facebook. We sat down with one of the nations elite combat veterans, now a renowned tactical trainer, and asked him why he thinks the AR-15 is the best home-defense gun you can buy. Its easy to find on most ammo shelves and isnt the most expensive choice. I love the shotgun. Of course, there are many more and every so often manufacturers release new 9mm carbines so its certainly not an end all be all type of list. Sponsored Post. 55-grain FMJ is ideal and cheap home defense ammo. Its one of the [] My thinking was that the carbine has a greater number of advantages. More Protect. The combination of these two parts make the AR9 very short and compact, perfect for home or self-defense. Admittedly, Thureon Defenses 9mm carbine almost doesnt qualify for this list. Story continues below the video But aside from those types of scenarios, Id pick a pistol-caliber carbine for those trickier 5 to 75 yarders, such as urban-to-rural bugout and home-defensive situations. She asked me to write up a Continue reading Carbine vs. Youre free to disagree, thats OK, we arent perfect. Id grab my AR-15 once Ive reached more open areas, or perhaps a Springfield XD if Im in a back alley and someone jeopardizes my life and limb. By. shotgun has several problems that make it less than adequate as a great home defense weapon Jason Hanson-October 27, 2015. Tags: .30 carbine, .357, ***, 9mm, ar-15, ar-9, carbine, cheap, controversy, One niche where I would like to see the pistol-caliber carbine expand into is that of an inexpensive home defense long gun, a market currently dominated by shotguns. Latest. It depends on the application. That said, a pistol caliber carbine (PCC) does have some very specific advantages in a home-defense scenario. That is where a fun gun like a 9mm AR-15 can slide in to fill a void in your enjoyment and in your training regimen. If you would like to know why I intend to switch our home defense gun from a shotgun to an AR-15 And why YOU may want to do the same then this article will explain everything. But if you look at the arguments we make here we feel sufficiently confident that you will also see that the AR-15 in 5.56/.223 is good for home defense but may not be OPTIMUM. AR15.COM is the worlds largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. The controls safety, mag release, trigger are intuitively positioned. In a home-defense situation, some of the upside of the long gun disappears when you need to use a hand to operate a light switch, guide a family member or hold a telephone to talk to authorities. There is one other option besides a pistol that was designed specifically for home defense. We just dont feel its So good for home defense that we would list 5 out of 10-12 rifles as variants of the AR-15. The AR-15 doesnt come with out some disadvantages as well. Coupled with the shorter barrel, lighter lower receiver, and lighter ammunition, the AR9 is also substantially lighter than the AR15.-Ammunition Prices: Shooting 9mm is about as cheap as Some people insist on running a rifle or AR-style set up though for various reasons. It is fun and since my AR-15 is my home defense gun, shooting it can be practical from a training standpoint as well. In widely circulated tests, a 115-grain 9mm JHP picks up an additional 200 fps of velocity when fired from a 16-inch barrel of a PCC versus the more traditional 4-inch barrel of a full-sized handgun and even higher with +P ammo (which should be the choice for personal defense with a carbine) putting a 9mm out of a PCC into the same fps ballpark as a .357 SIG fired from a pistol. The opposite is true for a carbine. Rails allow easy mounting of lights, lasers and optics. From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. For those of you looking for the 44 of pistols, there are several options. Pinterest. Shotgun vs. The die has long since been cast and the Stoner-based carbine is now the patrol rifle of choice for U.S. law enforcement. AR15.COM is the worlds largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types. I used to think the carbine was a better choice for home defense. Without actually seeing the subjects of this month s test, we imagined these two 9mm carbines as being a poor man s AR-15, or perhaps an MP5. Commonality of caliber and magazines is not a bad idea, but if you own a revolver, the 9mm carbine is still a good idea for home defense. A shooter can mod a 9mm carbine as much as an AR15. You've decided to get a long gun for home defense, but what should you get? This makes 9mm ammo at least 10x cheaper than AR ammo! Easier to Shoot Than Handguns. Pistol-Caliber Carbines for Home Defense: Setup & Strategy. We compare AR rifles to handguns and shotguns and break down the attributes of each. When youre dumping rounds with a pistol, dont expect to hit the target often. Higher capacity 4. They accept the Glock 33 round magazine in 9mm. Yet, quality made and reliable as a faithful dog, the Standard Carbine proves an The two short rifles in question are in fact the $575 Ruger PC9, which operates from magazines common to Ruger s P85-95 series pistols, and Hi-Point s 9mm Carbine, $199. Low recoil makes mastering form and control easier. This post is in response to a request from pax of www,corneredcat.com She is an excellent firearms instructor out of Washington state. The AR-15 is accurate, low recoil, lightweight, easy to shoot, customizable and highly versatile. For example, 9mm gets close to its peak muzzle energy around 7-10", whereas the AR-15's .223 is best with a barrel length of 18"+. July 27, 2018. Home; Tactical; Firearm Accessories; Carbine Training: 9mm vs. .223 Rem. Due to its wide range in application, its time to review some of the 9mm carbines that we see the most value in. Gun Reviews. Should You Consider an AR-15 for Home Defense? From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm. A 9mm is a very common caliber and one with respectable ballistics. So, it must be better It is true the carbine has more advantages: 1. Meanwhile, in a target shooting or competitive shooting application, a 9mm carbine will be effective against targets situated at 200 yards out. A double tap in the chest of most bad guys will keep you alive and them wishing they would have stayed home. Easier to operate by a non-shooting spouse 5. I dont yuck other peoples yum, so lets jump into the good and bad of AR self-defense in the home. 9mm carbines on the market are incredibly versatile, allowing more Americans to customize them than ever before. New for 2018, Rugers PC (pistol caliber) carbine looks to be an excellent choice for home defense, combining the best attributes of a handgun and a long gun in a home-defense weapon. In a self-defense setting, an effective range will be about 100 yards. Lets talk about the Hi-Point Carbine 45 vs 9mm. Shotgun for Home Defense. The 9mm won't magically start punching through body armor because you juiced it up. Carbines are a delight for shooters who enjoy tinkering. She knew that I was a big proponent of shoulder fired long guns, either carbines or shotguns for home defense, whereas she primarily favors the pistol. Hi Point Carbine 45 vs 9mm. I've talked a lot about pistol caliber carbines vs rifles, but what about compared to handguns. Why an AR-15 for home defense is the smart choice: At around 7 pounds it's maneuverable. Bumping its head on this article price ceiling, it starts to stretch the definition of affordable. First, let me get something out of the way first. If you read my posts on the Ruger 10/22 (part 1, part 2) that I set up for home defense, this post will contain echoes and similar logic to that series. Conclusion. Itll get the job done. Pistol for home defense ReddIt. Pistol Caliber Carbines. Range Life. The Special Application 9mm Carbine for Home Defense Part 1. Less recoil for faster follow up shots 2. 9mm Carbine vs AR 15 Carbine Faster and easier to reload 3. Benefits of Using an AR-15 for Home Defense. Rimfire Power. The 9mm hits pretty hard from a 16-inch barre,l so overall the 9mm is the best choicebut it depends upon the handgun. Share. We also dont have $1200 for an AR-15 pattern 9mm carbine.